遇见数据集

Data from: Investigating the timing of origin and evolutionary processes shaping regional species diversity: insights from simulated data and Neotropical butterfly diversification rates

收藏
DataONE2016-05-31 更新2024-06-26 收录
数据链接:
官方服务:

资源简介:

Different diversification scenarios have been proposed to explain the origin of extant biodiversity. However, most existing meta-analyses of time-calibrated phylogenies rely on approaches that do not quantitatively test alternative diversification processes. Here, I highlight the shortcomings of using species divergence ranks, which is a method widely used in meta-analyses. Divergence ranks consist of categorizing cladogenetic events to certain periods of time, typically to either Pleistocene or to pre-Pleistocene ages. This approach has been claimed to shed light on the origin of most extant species and the timing and dynamics of diversification in any biogeographical region. However, interpretations drawn from such method often confound two fundamental questions in macroevolutionary studies, tempo (timing of evolutionary rate shifts) and mode ("how" and "why" of speciation). By using simulated phylogenies under four diversification scenarios, constant-rate, diversity-dependence, high extinction and high speciation rates in the Pleistocene, I showed that interpretations based on species divergence ranks might have been seriously misleading. Future meta-analyses of dated phylogenies need to be aware of the impacts of incomplete taxonomic sampling, tree topology and divergence time uncertainties, as well as they might be benefited by including quantitative tests of alternative diversification models that acknowledge extinction and diversity-dependence.

已有多种多样化情景被提出,用以阐释现存生物多样性的起源。然而,当前多数针对时间校准系统发育树(time-calibrated phylogenies)的元分析(meta-analyses)所采用的研究方法,无法对不同的多样化过程开展定量检验。本文指出了物种分歧秩法(species divergence ranks)的固有缺陷——该方法在元分析领域被广泛应用。物种分歧秩法是将分支演化事件(cladogenetic events)划归至特定时间区间,通常分为更新世(Pleistocene)与更新世之前两个时段。该方法曾被认为可用于阐明多数现存物种的起源,以及任意生物地理区域内多样化过程的时间模式与动态特征。然而,依托该方法得出的解读结论,往往混淆了宏观演化(macroevolutionary)研究中的两个核心议题:一是速率时序(tempo,即演化速率变化的时间节点),二是演化模式(mode,即物种形成的‘方式与成因’)。本文借助四种多样化情景下生成的模拟系统发育树——涵盖恒定速率、依赖多样性、高灭绝速率以及更新世高物种形成速率情景——证实,基于物种分歧秩法的解读可能存在严重误导性。未来针对时间校准系统发育树的元分析,需充分意识到不完整分类采样、树拓扑结构(tree topology)以及分歧时间不确定性(divergence time uncertainties)所带来的影响;同时,纳入针对考虑灭绝与依赖多样性的多样化备选模型的定量检验,或将为相关研究提供助益。

创建时间:
2016-05-31
二维码
社区交流群
二维码
科研交流群
商业服务