Simulating the Effects of Behavioral and Physical Heterogeneity on Nonpoint Source Pollution
收藏资源简介:
To increase the effectiveness of conservation programs focused on reducing agricultural nutrient runoff and targeting management interventions, some have called for greater attention to the role of diversity in both management and physical context. To examine the independent and interactive effects of behavioral and physical heterogeneity on phosphorus loads, a sensitivity analysis was conducted using six different assumptions about distributions of phosphorus fertilizer application rates and soil test phosphorus (STP) levels for hydrologic response units in a SWAT model for the Maumee River Watershed. Results indicated that changing assumptions about behavior and STP levels can significantly affect estimated dissolved reactive phosphorus (DRP) loads and the level of disproportionality, which is a measure of the unequal distribution of pollutant loading. Placing the highest fertilizer application rates on fields with the most excessive STP produced 14% greater estimated DRP load and higher levels of disproportionality compared to a baseline model, where homogeneity in farmer fertilizer behavior and STP was assumed. In contrast, placing the lowest fertilizer application rates on the fields with the most excessive STP led to estimated DRP loads and level of disproportionality that were similar to the baseline model. Results from this analysis suggest that simplistic or uniform assumptions about behavior or STP levels may mask serious environmental risks in agricultural watershed models.
为提升针对削减农业养分径流、靶向开展管理干预的保护项目实施实效,部分研究呼吁更多关注管理维度与物理环境两方面的多样性作用。为探究行为异质性与物理异质性对磷负荷的独立及交互影响,本研究针对莫米河流域(Maumee River Watershed)的SWAT模型,设置6种关于水文响应单元(hydrologic response units)的磷肥施用量分布与土壤测试磷(soil test phosphorus, STP)水平的不同假设,开展敏感性分析。研究结果显示,调整关于施肥行为与STP水平的假设,可显著影响溶解态活性磷(dissolved reactive phosphorus, DRP)负荷的估算值,以及表征污染物负荷不均分布程度的非均衡性水平。相较于假定农户施肥行为与STP水平均一的基准模型,将最高磷肥施用量分配至STP水平最高超标田块的方案,其估算的DRP负荷高出14%,且非均衡性水平更高。与之相反,将最低磷肥施用量分配至STP水平最高超标田块的方案,其估算的DRP负荷与非均衡性水平均与基准模型相近。本分析结果表明,针对施肥行为或STP水平采用简化或均一化假设,可能会掩盖农业流域模型中潜在的重大环境风险。



