Data from: Hedging your bets: intermediate movements as optimal behavior in the context of an incomplete decision
收藏资源简介:
Existing theories of movement planning suggest that it takes time to select and prepare the actions required to achieve a given goal. These theories often appeal to circumstances where planning apparently goes awry. For instance, if reaction times are forced to be very low, movement trajectories are often directed between two potential targets. These intermediate movements are generally interpreted as errors of movement planning, arising either from planning being incomplete or from parallel movement plans interfering with one another. Here we present an alternative view: that intermediate movements reflect uncertainty about movement goals. We show how intermediate movements are predicted by an optimal feedback control model that incorporates an ongoing decision about movement goals. According to this view, intermediate movements reflect an exploitation of compatibility between goals. Consequently, reducing the compatibility between goals should reduce the incidence of intermediate movements. In human subjects, we varied the compatibility between potential movement goals in two distinct ways: by varying the spatial separation between targets and by introducing a virtual barrier constraining trajectories to the target and penalizing intermediate movements. In both cases we found that decreasing goal compatibility led to a decreasing incidence of intermediate movements. Our results and theory suggest a more integrated view of decision-making and movement planning in which the primary bottleneck to generating a movement is deciding upon task goals. Determining how to move to achieve a given goal is rapid and automatic.
现有运动规划理论认为,为实现特定目标所需的动作选择与准备环节需要消耗一定时长。这类理论常以规划明显失误的场景作为佐证:例如,当反应时被强制降至极低水平时,运动轨迹往往会在两个潜在目标之间产生偏移。这类中间运动通常被解读为运动规划错误,其诱因要么是规划尚未完成,要么是并行运动规划之间产生了相互干扰。本文提出一种全新视角:中间运动实则反映了运动目标的不确定性。我们证实,纳入了运动目标持续决策过程的最优反馈控制(optimal feedback control)模型,能够对中间运动进行预测。根据该理论框架,中间运动本质上是对目标间兼容性的利用。据此可推导,降低目标间的兼容性应当能够减少中间运动的发生概率。我们通过两种截然不同的方式调控人类被试的潜在运动目标间的兼容性:一是调整目标间的空间间距,二是引入虚拟屏障限制运动轨迹朝向目标,并对中间运动施加惩罚。在两种实验范式下,我们均观察到:目标兼容性越低,中间运动的发生率也就越低。我们的研究结果与理论共同支撑了决策与运动规划的整合视角:生成运动的核心瓶颈在于确定任务目标,而为达成既定目标规划运动路径的过程则是快速且自动化的。



